Unreachable Churned Customer (High LTV)
60-day risk free trial
Who Is Alua?
Alua is a Dutch collagen brand built around a 100% biological collagen powder designed to dissolve easily and actually taste good, a category where both of those things are harder to get right than they sound. The brand has grown quickly in the Netherlands, building a loyal, repeat-driven customer base around a daily supplement habit.
That repeat-purchase model means a churned customer isn't just a missed order, it's someone who broke a daily routine they'd built around the product, and potentially a high-value customer worth winning back specifically.
Churned Customers, All Unreachable
Alua had a segment of customers who'd churned and gone fully unreachable across email, SMS and web, the usual channels for reactivation already exhausted. Among them sat an unknown mix of value, some lower-spend one-off buyers, and some genuinely high-LTV customers worth a disproportionate amount of effort to recover.
Without a way to tell those two groups apart, there was no way to know whether the flow was working as well as it could, or where the real opportunity actually sat.
Testing First, Then Targeting The Cohort That Outperforms
Paper Run first ran this as a genuine holdout test, an automated mailer sent to churned, unreachable customers and measured against a true control group rather than raw attribution. That test alone confirmed a real, incremental effect.
From there, Paper Run applied its cohort analysis tool to the same churned audience, sub-segmenting the flow by customer value to find out which part of the base was actually driving the result. That analysis surfaced a clear answer: high-LTV churned customers outperformed the rest of the segment by a wide margin, and the flow was re-targeted to hyper-focus on exactly that cohort.
Finding, Then Focusing On, The Cohort That Actually Performs
The flow is delivering a 2.03X incremental ROAS and a +37% conversion uplift against a genuine holdout, with high-LTV churned customers identified through Paper Run's cohort analysis as the segment driving the strongest returns. Rather than treating every churned customer the same, Alua now knows precisely which part of that audience is worth prioritising.
That's the real value of testing before scaling, the holdout proved the channel worked, and the cohort analysis showed exactly where to point it for the best return.
Running this through a genuine holdout test told us the flow worked. Running it through Paper Run's cohort analysis told us something more valuable, exactly which churned customers were worth going after hardest. Being able to hyper-target our high-LTV churned customers off the back of that is a different level of precision than we'd normally get from a winback flow.
Founder, Alua
Book
Setup time with the Paper Run team and learn how the world's best DTC brands are using Direct Mail.
More amazing stories
Read more about how rockstar brands are converting customers who don't open their emails.

















