Unreachable Cancelled Subscriber
60-day risk free trial
Who Is Wilsons Pet Food?
Wilsons Pet Food traces its roots back over 150 years to a grain and feed merchant in Scotland, making it one of the longest-established pet food businesses in the UK. Today the Ayrshire-based brand produces cold-pressed dog food, built around a subscription model that delivers automatically so owners never have to remember to reorder.
With that much of the business built on recurring subscriptions, a cancelled subscriber represents a customer who'd already committed to a regular feeding routine for their dog, making them a meaningfully different, and often more recoverable, prospect than someone who never subscribed at all.
Cancelled Subscribers, Gone Quiet
Wilsons had a pool of customers who'd cancelled their dog food subscription and then stopped engaging entirely, no email opens, no clicks, no site visits. For a subscription business, that combination is particularly costly, these were owners who'd already built a feeding routine around the brand, not cold prospects needing persuading from scratch.
With every digital channel already unable to reach them, there was no way left to remind these owners that the subscription, and the routine it supported, was still there waiting.
An Automated Mailer For Lapsed Routines
Paper Run built an automated mailer specifically for cancelled subscribers who'd gone fully unreachable across digital channels, triggering without any manual intervention as soon as a customer met the cancelled-and-unreachable criteria. For a brand built on a dog's daily feeding habit, a physical mailer gave Wilsons a way to reconnect that digital channels no longer could.
The flow runs continuously in the background, catching cancelled subscribers at the exact point they'd otherwise have been written off for good.
Restarting The Routine
The flow is driving a 7.4X ROAS and a 5.84% conversion rate from cancelled subscribers who'd gone completely dark on every other channel, turning a lapsed routine back into an active one. For a subscription pet food brand, winning back a cancelled subscriber isn't just a single order, it's the restart of a recurring relationship.
That makes this a meaningfully different win than acquiring a brand-new customer, these were owners who already trusted Wilsons enough to subscribe once, and simply needed the right nudge to pick the habit back up.
Cancelled subscribers who've gone quiet on email are some of the hardest customers to win back through any digital channel, but they're also some of our most valuable if we can reach them. This flow has given us a reliable way to do exactly that, and a 7.4X ROAS speaks for itself.
Retention and Ecommerce Manager, Wilsons Pet Food
Book
Setup time with the Paper Run team and learn how the world's best DTC brands are using Direct Mail.
More amazing stories
Read more about how rockstar brands are converting customers who don't open their emails.

















